The “What do you like in a mystery/cozy mystery series” poll results
It took a while, but I finally managed to go through all the responses from my mystery series survey. I’ve posted them below so you can see what your fellow readers like (from plots to covers to authors you might like to try!) I really appreciate all your feedback, and I thought of a question I wish I’d asked:
What are your interests/hobbies/spare-time activities? Let me know below!
Knowing more about the things that make you happy make it easier for me to make you happy with my books! If you don’t mind sharing, please comment on this post with the various ways you like to spend your spare time/the things that make you happy! From pets and cooking (which might be no-brainers for my cozy readers) to collecting, painting, specific TV shows — anything you can think of that would help me find common threads among my readers.
One of the reasons I ask is because it turns out people who like fantasy tend to like mythology…and mythology is now a big sub-genre of fantasy. Trying to find the new big sub-genres!
Do you like the beach as a location? Yes
What’s Your Favorite Age for the Lead(s)? Doesn’t Matter/40-50
Do you prefer a man or woman lead character? Woman
Do you like your mysteries to have a bit of romance? Yes
Do you prefer lead rich, poor or in-between? Doesn’t Matter/InBetween
Favorite Elements of a Cozy
- I love the interactions with the town people. And I love town or area descriptions.
- Engaging supporting characters (many times)
- A comic side kick. Not have to be roll on the floor funny but kinda smartass if you will. Do not make the lead a dumb blonde or ditzy like. Can’t stand that.
- I like them to keep me guessing who did it.
- (many times)
- A few red herrings. If there is a beach, there must be a storm and a morning after (nothing compares)
- I like interesting stories surrounding the characters. Their interactions and learning about them through the course of the series. I tend to shy away from those with an underlying story that never seems to be revealed or solved. That causes me to lose interest. And i really enjoy when a loved fur baby is involved. (especially cats)
- Engaging characters esp if it is a series. Stand alone is not important as I always start with first book and go forward.
- Interesting hobby or disease or collection. And pets specifically beagles.
- Not a divorce it’s been overdone and is tiring.
- A twist no one expects at the end. I hate figuring it out before I’m halfway through the book.
- Laughter at fumbling self-important cops who don’t listen. Nosy neighbors. Snarky and sassy solvers who irritate just enough to force mistakes.
- I tend to enjoy cozies with a somewhat accident prone heroine, probably because I can relate to awkward and unusual accidents lol
- Just keep up with some humor and strong female lead
- I like to read things that make me laugh out loud but also has a good mystery plot.
- Pets, bumbling police, silly relatives, amazing best friend…
- Realistic story line
- While it doesn’t matter if the lead is a man or a woman, I love the lead to have both intelligence and a sense of humor. Animals are also welcome. I love the plot to be twisty, with the final mystery to be exceptionally difficult to solve, but it MUST make sense.
- Great, fun characters that are interesting and have a depth to them.
- I want a real challenge – I DON’T want to figure out ‘whodunnit’ by chapter 3. Cats and dogs -small breed dogs. Books, reading, library, bookshops. No loose ends unless that part of the storyline will play out in the series but it has to be mentioned or setup at or near the end – don’t leave reader hanging unless it’s been setup. I know the writer needs to have clues in the story but not obvious ones. I don’t like screaming at my Kindle cause the heroine doesn’t get it. People look at me funny. I also like magic or witches. I know that edges toward fantasy but I’ve read some good series like that, like Heather Blake’s Wishcraft Mysteries.
- Overcoming an everyday hardship like we all do in the real world
- Ones that have a surprise ending
- Please not too scary, especially the end. Of course there is a murder and the lead character has to fin Age of leads should reflect their experience. Sometimes they’re irrationally young. Good dialog.
- Lots and lots of sarcasm.
- I think having a 40 something female main character will give you lots of room to play with everything from aging issues to maybe second life/career issues. Just make sure she has a dog!
- Doesn’t matter if it is a man, woman or couple. Same for romance. Love a little humor. Plot twist is good, something unexpected.
- Quirky characters, bit of snark. Many of us read because we can’t stand to watch TV these days. I ended up reading this genre as I found I was burned out on the heavier thrillers which were mostly attempting to mirror or amplify real life. Basically escapism. Some quirky characters, a smart mouthed hero/heroine, and little or no gore. Some of the paranormals are quite entertaining especially those that don’t get bogged down in magic and ritual but are light hearted.
- I love mysteries with mystical antiquities in them and even some crazy fun time travel.
- Suspense of course! Laughter but seriousness when needed….I can tell you that I’ve been holding my breath while a serious or pivotal moment builds up…and the character’s sense of humour can relieve the tension…so much that I break out in laughter and wake my husband! There can be death…a murder….but please don’t involve children as victims. I find those books hard to handle.
What sort of covers attract you
- Kitty Confidential by Molly Fitz. Cakewalk to Murder by MK Scott
- I might be a bug as I like bright colors and shiny things
- Not quick done or cheesey
- Maybe scary looking house or landscape.desolate or snowy.or a beach with a cliff .
- I like the covers that does not show a person.
- The ones that are not cartoons or R-rated
- Something that involves the story. Carmen Harris
- No preference as it does not impact my reading as much as the short summary of book
- Hand drawn, or cartoony.
- I like those that make you curious to see what inside. Those I always read the synopsis.
- Not sure, I find that I don’t like too dark or real people for some reason. Illustrated is better and colorful
- I’ve really liked all of your covers.
- Small details that somehow pertain to the storyline
- I tend to go by the blurb first, then remember the cover only later.
- I love all your covers. Haha. Bright and cheeery.
- The cover should reflect the book. Think about when a reader has only a cover to judge your book like on NetGalley or perusing Amazon. The cover matters! If it looks like a cozy mystery, I will look further but if the cover has a dark or suspenseful look or is silly, I keep going.
- I am rather sick of covers with shirtless males.
- I like the new cover designs for the Pineapple Port series. Bright and eye-catching. Not big on the all pastel covers.
- Bright Colors, Quirky Characters, Teasers. More Illustrated than photographic. Jana DeLeon has some of the best for her Miss Fortune Series.
- Unless there is some humor in it, I do not like the cartoony covers as much.
- I like covers similar to what the book shop mysteries have….having said that….I don’t judge a book by its cover….but it does draw original attention….
Authors You Like
MENTIONED MORE THAN ONCE:
- Amanda Lee
- Amy Boyles
- Amy Vansant (I should hope so, it was my survey! J )
- Ann Charles
- Anna Celeste Burke
- Carla Neggers
- Daisy Prescott
- Hope Callaghan
- Jana DeLeon
- Janet Elizabeth Henderson
- Joanne Fluke
- Kathi Daley
- Mary Higgins Clark
- Morgana Best
- Nora Roberts
- Sam Cheever
- Sarah MacLean
- Summer Prescott
- Tonya Kappes
- Willow Rose
- Adele Abbott
- AGATHA CHRISTIE
- Alex Ericson
- Alison Golden
- Amanda Flower
- Anabel Chase
- Angie Fox
- Ani Gonzalez
- Anni Gonzales
- Anni Jayde
- Bailey Cates
- Barbara Delinsky
- Book Retreat Mysteries
- Booktown Mysteries
- Carol Higgins Clark
- Carolyn Ridder Aspenson
- Cats in the Stack series
- Chelsea Thomas
- Cindy Sample
- Cyndi Raye
- Deany Ray
- Debbie Dunlop
- Denise g Swank
- Destiny Ford
- Diane Mott Davidson
- Diane Vallere
- Duffy Browns
- Ellery Adams
- Ellis Peters
- Emily kimelman
- Frances Brody
- Frances Lockridge
- Gemma Halliday
- Hannah Howell
- Harper Harris
- Heather Blake
- Hope Sinclair
- A Jance
- James Patterson
- Janet Evanovich
- Jenn McKinlay
- Jenna Bennett
- Jordana Sydney Robinson
- Joyce St John
- Juliet Blackwell
- Kate Carlisle
- Katie Wyatt
- Lee Hollis
- Lillian Jackson Braun
- Lily Harper Hart
- LL Muir
- Lorna Barrett/Lorraine Bartlett
- Lorraine Bartlett
- Lyndsey Cole
- Lynne Cahoon
- Maddie Day
- Magic Potion mysteries
- Magical Bakery mysteries
- Mary Marks
- Miranda James
- MK Scott
- Molly Fitz
- Mona Marple
- Nancy McGovern
- Patricia Cornwall
- Rae Davies
- Raven Snow
- Rita Mae Brown’s “Mrs Murphy Mysteries”
- Robert Dugoni
- Rose Pressey
- RP dahlke
- Sheila Connelly
- Sherryl Woods
- Sofia Kelly
- Stacy Alabaster
- Stephanie Bond
- Tegan Maher
- Tressa Trent
- Vicky Vass
- Victoria L K Williams
- Wishcraft series
(2) Winners of eBook “Gift Baskets of ALL books pictured!
(15+) Winners of individual ebooks or paperbacks (randomly selected)
Start Date: 07-23-2019End Date: 07-30-2019
Every Good Deed
By River Ames
When Linc met Erin in college, she was already engaged to his best friend. From the moment he first laid eyes on her, a war commenced within him. On one side, the need to resist his attraction to her, and on the other to have her for his own.Erin Clay, widowed, is raising a son, who’s turning five come September. Growing up as a minister’s daughter, she received a lot of well-meaning charity—donations comprised primarily from the cast-off clothing her schoolmates no longer wanted.When Erin was in college, she’d been swept off her feet by Merrill Clay. He was sophisticated, wealthy, and self-assured. Handsome, too, he’d introduced her to a world that seemed to have all the things her own life had lacked. With stars in her eyes and her head in the clouds, how could she say no to his marriage proposal?It’s been a year since Merrill’s death, much too soon for her to be developing feelings for Linc Severance, her late-husband’s business partner and former best friend.If Erin is no longer certain that she married Merrill for the right reasons, how can she trust her growing awareness and feelings for Linc?She’s no longer a young and naive college student. With a son to care for, it’s vital that she put away her girlish dreams of passion and love. And, as for Linc, he’s determined to untangle his former partner’s business interests from Erin’s finances. Then, he’ll disappear from her life forever. He’s wasted too many years loving a woman never met to be his.