The Apple Pie Defense

apple pie recipe

The story of how an apple pie saved me – first published in Skirt! Magazine.


Grief is a master of disguise. Like a vampire, it drains self-respect until you’re openly sobbing in the grocery store because they’re out of spray butter.  It masquerades as a hypnotist, fixing your gaze on one small patch of sofa for days. It is a ninja, ambushing as you walk into a room that used to feel less empty.

Sometimes, grief is a pastry chef.

Divorce and a string of family deaths had made 1999 a hard year for me. Trying to recreate my Great-Grandmom’s apple pie recipe seemed a pro-active way to break my slide into depression. Every birthday and Christmas dinner of my childhood ended with Great-Grandmom’s apple pie, and these were all happy times, unless you were hoping for cake. If you wanted cake, you were out of luck until my brother’s birthday.

Grief had planted that seed in my head. I realized that somewhere around pie number thirteen.

I had Great-Grandmom’s recipe folded and tucked in my recipe box. After years of cajoling, my Mom-Mom, Great-Grandmom’s daughter-in-law, had finally gotten it out of the old lady. Mom-mom thought Great-Grandmom had finally gone soft and thrown up the white flag in the form of an apple pie recipe.

HA. Great-Grandmom’s kitchen was rimmed with an impressive salt and pepper shaker collection, filled with old cloth calendars-turned dish towels, and covered by an asbestos tile floor, but you’d be hard pressed to find a white flag anywhere.  When Mom-Mom danced off with the coveted recipe, Great-Grandmom smoothed out her house dress with her impossibly large German hands, sat down at her chrome-legged kitchen table, and laughed herself silly.

She might as well as given Mom-Mom directions for Shepherd’s Pie, for all that slip of paper had in common with the real apple pie recipe.

Not long after, Great-Grandmom died, the real recipe locked beneath her steel gray curls.

Great-Grandmom- 1, Mom-Mom-0. Game over.

I could taste their disdain for each other as I sampled my first attempt at the faux recipe. The filling had no magic; the crust, leaden.

The crust I could cure. My Nanny, my mother’s mother, had a perfect crust. Nanny had no animosity towards her own daughter, so that recipe I could trust.

Second attempt: Crust perfect. Filling: terrible; no better than cafeteria pie.

Over the next week I made 16 pies, each time tweaking the ingredients to no avail. Roma apples, green apples, gala apples. I had gotten very close with a combination of gala and green apples, but still, the pie lacked something. Something that made it Great-Grandmom’s apple pie.

Grief had turned me into an obsessive-compulsive pie-baking lunatic.

I found myself sitting in defeat, flour coating my kitchen like Christmas morning snow, sipping on a bourbon.  I dribbled the last of the bourbon into my glass. Not only had I not recreated the pie, but now I was out of bourbon.

I could hear Grief’s buddies Maudlin and Self-Pity knocking on the door.

My eyes tilted towards my glass-paneled cupboard, home to my liquor collection.  I opened a bottle of gin and sniffed. Nope. I couldn’t move from bourbon to the bitter  juniper berry scent of gin. I opened a bottle of rum. No, no. Too sweet. Wrong, wrong, wrong.

My eyes fell on a cheap bottle of Canadian whiskey. It wasn’t something I drank, but I had this romantic idea that someday an elderly neighbor would stop by and tell me stories about the Great War, and I would be the perfect hostess, trotting out the Seagram’s Seven.

I opened the whiskey and inhaled. Nope. I started tightening the cap, but… that smell. Somewhere in my sad, foggy brain, a bulb began to glow.

The whiskey smelled like Great-Grandmom’s pie.

I leapt to my feet and prepared the crust for another pie and added a cup of whiskey to the filling.  As it baked I cleaned. I cleaned the flour off the walls and floor. I put the dishes in the dishwasher. I moved into other rooms, picking up weeks of clothes, scattered books and photos.  As the pie cooled, I resisted the urge to burn my tongue and pushed myself to clean more. Finally, I took a long hot shower and removed the flour from my face and the pie dough from my fingernails.

Towel drying my hair, the smell of warm apple pie led me back into the kitchen, the scent different than the pungent combination of apple and defeat that had hung in the air for the last week. I closed my eyes and pictured the red table cloth at Christmas, my mother’s good china coffee cups sitting in front of each family member, an apple pie plate placed in front of me.

I cut into the dessert and tasted.

I had recreated the pie.

An intoxicating aroma hugged my kitchen like the embrace of a big German grandmother.

The calendar on the wall reminded me the ladies’ book club that I used to enjoy was scheduled for the next evening.  I had been hiding, Grief and I. It was time to go out.

The next morning I stocked up at the grocery store and started baking more pies. I made one for each of the six ladies of book club. Moans of joy filled the air as they took their first forkfuls, and my heart swelled with happiness. Mission accomplished.

Driving home after book club, triumphant and lost in my thoughts, I didn’t at first notice the red and blue lights flashing behind me.  I’d been speeding. My stomach lurched. I pulled over.

As the officer leaned into my window I saw him pause and sniff the air.

“Have you been drinking tonight?” he asked.

I smiled, knowing I hadn’t had a drop to drink that night. The quest to dull my pain had been accomplished by pie, no alcohol required.


“Your car smells like whiskey,” said the officer, raising an eyebrow.

I sniffed. My car did smell like whiskey.

“Pies,” I said. “I took everyone in my book club apple pies made with whiskey for Christmas. I’m sure the car smells like a distillery.”

The officer nodded and looked away, the corner of his mouth curling to form a barely perceptible grin.

“My grandmother had booze in her pies too,” he said. Without further argument, he handed me back my license, and sent me off with a warning.

The apple pie defense had set me free.


Want the recipe? HERE IT IS!

Amy Vansant

20 Responses

  1. Raymond

    Apple pie and whiskey! These are some of my favourite things. (And whiskers on kittens too I suppose…)

    Great article. 🙂


  2. Nicole

    Oh how true this rings. Though so many of her amazing dishes left with her, I have successfully recreated my Nana’s chicken soup. But it only works if I ask her for a little help before I start. 🙂

    Loved this.


  3. Cheryl Talma

    Hmmmm . . . I always thought my Grandma threw in an extra dose of love when she baked and that’s why it never tasted the same. Turns out she probably used whiskey too lol!


  4. Lance

    I wonder if Jack Daniels would be better in apple pie? hmmmmm

    at least I know I’d never bee without a drink at your house.


    • Amy Vansant

      No, no one leaves my house alive. Even moms and grandmothers end up tipsy – and they’re the most fun to get that way.

      Jack would probably work just fine.


  5. SarcasticNinja

    I have found that almost all recipes can be improved by adding some alcohol. As long as you include the baking in the grief-defeating equation as well as the alcohol…


  6. Lynn Kellan

    Delightful story! I’m in charge of Thanksgiving dinner this year, so I may try a little whiskey in our apple pie, too.


  7. Tammy

    Great story! Grandmas are awesome, whether they cook brilliantly or not. And seriously, some don’t. You’re one of the lucky ones!



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.